Band 5 IELTS Writing Task 2 Essay: Owning vs Renting a Home - Clarity Issues
Sample Answer with Feedback

πŸ“… Published Mar 2026 ⏱️ 40 minutes recommended πŸ“ 258 words Β· Band 5
✏️ Start Writing for Free
This Band 5 IELTS essay discusses the advantages and disadvantages of owning a home versus renting. While it touches on valid points, clarity issues and underdeveloped arguments limit its effectiveness. Focusing on improving vocabulary and coherence can significantly enhance the overall quality of your writing.

IELTS Writing Task 2 Question

Advantages/ Disadvantages Β· House Ownership Β· 40 min


The choice between owning and renting a home involves a careful consideration of various factors that can positively and negatively affect one's life. What are the advantages and disadvantages of owning a house compared to renting one?

Write at least 250 words.

 



5 Band

Overall Band Score

258 words · Advantages/ Disadvantages Β· AI Evaluated

5
Task Response
5
Coherence
4.5
Lexical Resource
4.5
Grammar

Score Breakdown

IELTS Writing Band Scores (1–9)

Task Response
5
Coherence and Cohesion
5
Lexical Resource
4.5
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
4.5

Summary: The essay meets the minimum word count (258 words) and addresses the topic by discussing advantages and disadvantages of owning versus renting. However, the arguments are underdeveloped, with some irrelevant or unclear points, and there are issues with vocabulary range and grammatical accuracy, which limit clarity and cohesion.

Now write your own β€” and see how your verdict holds up.

Submit your House Ownership essay and receive AI scores across Task Response, Coherence, Lexical Resource, and Grammar β€” plus a Band 9 model answer for your exact question.

Student Answer
Real submission β€’ 258 words β€’ Annotated
258 words Band 5 WritingPart2
● Spelling ● Grammar ● Vocabulary

People often think buying a house is more secure. The choice between owning and renting a house depends on the individual. This essay will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of owning a house compared to renting one.

To begin, one significant benefit of owning a house is its ownership. The ability to declare having one's own property makes people more secure about their future. For instance, in an Asian family or society, it is mostly considered that people who have their own home are the worthy ones. In addition, having one's own house means the individual doesn't need to worry about paying rent for the next month. This helps in saving at least a little sum of money, and people can invest in the stock market or other profitable outcomes.

However, owning a house presents some drawbacks. One noticeable disadvantage is that people have to invest a significant amount of their earnings. Renting the house doesn't require a large amount of money; you can pay your rent in installments, and people can also invest in a profitable business, which later could help in the betterment of their future. It's very efficient to rent a new house if it's not suitable, but one can't change their mind after buying a house. However, investing all your savings in one land or house and not having any savings could lead to frustration later.

In conclusion, owning a house ensures the guarantee of protection. Nevertheless, it poses challenges such as limited investment in businesses, and it can sometimes affect your mental health.

AI Feedback Report Details

Spelling Β· Grammar Β· Vocabulary Β· Criteria Analysis

Spelling Mistakes

0 errors
No spelling mistakes found.

Grammatical Mistakes

0 errors
No grammatical mistakes found.

Vocabulary Improvements

8 suggestions
Original Word/Phrase Improved Word/Phrase Explanation
are the worthy ones are deemed worthy Vague phrasing; 'deemed worthy' is more precise and academic.
a little sum of money a small amount of money Informal and vague; 'a small amount of money' is clearer and more appropriate for academic writing.
profitable outcomes profitable investments Wrong collocation; 'outcomes' is not typically used with 'profitable' in this context. 'Investments' or 'ventures' are better alternatives.
betterment of their future improvement of their future prospects 'Betterment' is less common in formal writing; 'improvement' is more standard, and 'future prospects' adds clarity.
very efficient more convenient 'Efficient' refers to productivity with minimal waste; in the context of renting, 'convenient' or 'flexible' is more appropriate.
change their mind alter their decision Informal phrase; 'alter their decision' is more formal and precise.
ensures the guarantee of protection provides security Redundant phrasing; 'ensures the guarantee' is repetitive. 'Provides security' is concise and clear.
affect your mental health affect one's mental health Inconsistent pronoun use; in academic writing, 'one's' is preferred over 'your' for formal consistency.

Ready to practise? Get instant AI feedback on your verdict.

Submit your House Ownership essay and receive AI scores across all four IELTS criteria β€” with specific feedback on whether your solutions are specific, realistic, and matched to your problems.

Detailed Criteria Feedback

AI-powered analysis for each scoring criterion

Task Response 5
Evaluation
The essay attempts to cover both advantages and disadvantages, but the development is limited and some points lack relevance or clarity. For example, the mention of Asian society is not fully explained, and the financial arguments are contradictory in places.
Examples
Advantages include security and not paying rent, but the point about 'worthy ones' in Asian society is a broad generalization. Disadvantages mention large investment and lack of flexibility, but the comparison with renting is not consistently articulated.
How to Improve
Focus on clear, specific points for each side. For advantages, discuss long-term financial benefits, stability, and freedom to modify property. For disadvantages, address high upfront costs, maintenance responsibilities, and reduced mobility. Ensure each point is explained with logical examples and avoid irrelevant details.
Coherence and Cohesion 5
Evaluation
The essay has a basic structure with an introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion. However, cohesion is mechanical, and the flow between ideas is sometimes disrupted by abrupt transitions or unclear connections.
Examples
In the second body paragraph, 'However' introduces drawbacks, but the following sentences shift between renting benefits and buying drawbacks without clear linking. The conclusion is vague and does not effectively summarize the main points.
How to Improve
Use a wider range of cohesive devices (e.g., 'in contrast,' 'furthermore,' 'consequently') to show relationships between ideas. Ensure each paragraph has a clear topic sentence and that sentences logically follow one another. Practice writing conclusions that restate key arguments without introducing new information.
Lexical Resource 4.5
Evaluation
Vocabulary is basic and repetitive, with some inaccurate word choices that reduce precision. The range is limited, and there is little use of topic-specific or advanced vocabulary.
Examples
Phrases like 'profitable outcomes' (should be 'investment opportunities'), 'worthy ones' (awkward for 'respected' or 'successful'), and overuse of 'house' and 'owning' without synonyms.
How to Improve
Expand lexical range by learning synonyms (e.g., 'property' for 'house,' 'acquire' for 'own,' 'lease' for 'rent'). Incorporate topic-related terms like 'equity,' 'mortgage,' 'tenancy,' and 'landlord.' Practice using vocabulary in context to improve accuracy and avoid repetition.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy 4.5
Evaluation
Grammar is limited to simple structures, with several errors that affect clarity and meaning. There are issues with sentence construction, word order, and article usage.
Examples
Awkward phrasing: 'The ability to declare having one's own property' (better: 'The ability to claim ownership of property'). Incorrect use: 'people who have their own home are the worthy ones' (should be 'considered more successful' or similar). Run-on sentences and punctuation errors are present.
How to Improve
Practice constructing complex sentences using clauses and connectors (e.g., relative clauses, conditionals). Focus on subject-verb agreement, correct article usage ('a' vs. 'the'), and punctuation. Proofread essays to identify and correct recurrent errors, and consider using grammar check tools for feedback.
πŸ’‘
Tip: Review the Band 9 model answer to see how a high-scoring essay structures arguments, uses advanced vocabulary, and maintains coherence throughout.

RELATED ESSAYS

02
House Ownership πŸ“ 305 words ⏱️ Jun 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
The choice between owning and renting a home involves a careful consideration of various factors that can positively and negatively affect one's life. What are the advantages and disadvantages of owning a house compared to renting one? Write at least 250 words. 
It has been observed that, we have to consider many factors in choosing between owning and renting a house which have both positive and negative effects. There...
03
House Ownership πŸ“ 327 words ⏱️ Jun 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
The choice between owning and renting a home involves a careful consideration of various factors that can positively and negatively affect one's life. What are the advantages and disadvantages of owning a house compared to renting one? Write at least 250 words. 
Owning a house or renting a home has advantages as well as disadvantages. This essay will agree that owning a house is better than renting. Houses ar...
04
Technology πŸ“ 291 words ⏱️ Jun 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is increasingly being used to create art, music, and other forms of creative work. What are the advantages and disadvantages of this trend?Write at least 250 words.
Nowadays many people used artificial intelligence to make art, music and many other design work . Although this development may create some challenges, I believ...
05
Internet πŸ“ 258 words ⏱️ Jun 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
The internet is often seen as a way of shrinking the world by connecting people from different places. Discuss the arguments for and against the idea that the internet has simplified communication between individuals and provide your own opinion on the matter.
The internet is often described as a technology that has “shrunk the world” by making communication between people in different locations almost instantaneous. ...
06
Internet πŸ“ 272 words ⏱️ Jun 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
The internet is often seen as a way of shrinking the world by connecting people from different places. Discuss the arguments for and against the idea that the internet has simplified communication between individuals and provide your own opinion on the matter.
The internet has transformed communication by eliminating geographical and temporal barriers. While some argue that it has brought people closer, others believe...