Band 5.5 IELTS Writing Task 2 Discuss Both Views Essay: Income Limitations and Task Response Issues
Sample Answer with Feedback

many countries, a small number of people earn extremely high incomes. Some believe this situation benefits the nation, while others argue that governments should limit how much individuals can earn. This essay discusses both views and gives my opinion.Supporters of very high incomes claim they drive economic growth and national prosperity. High earners usually pay more tax, providing governments with extra revenue to improve public services such as education, healthcare, and transport. Moreover, the possibility of earning large sums encourages people to work harder, develop new skills, and take entrepreneurial risks. Many wealthy business owners create companies that employ thousands of workers and introduce innovative products. If governments restrict income, motivation may decline and talented professionals might move to countries offering better financial rewards.In contrast, opponents argue that unlimited incomes increase inequality and social problems. When wealth is concentrated in the hands of a few, the gap between rich and poor widens, which can lead to frustration, crime, and social instability. In addition, extremely wealthy individuals may gain excessive political influence, allowing them to shape policies for personal benefit rather than the public good. Those who support income limits believe governments should ensure fairer wealth distribution so that everyone can

It is often debated whether governments should have the power to control the salaries of the highest earners in society. Some people claim that allowing individuals to earn as much as they want benefits the country, while others, including me, argue that a maximum wage should be implemented. In this essay, I will examine both perspectives and present my own view.

On the one hand, some people support the idea of allowing individuals to earn exceptionally high incomes, believing that this fosters competition and innovation. Those with exceptional skills, knowledge, and experience can command high salaries from their employers, attracting more talent and investment to the country. For example, renowned professionals such as Dr. Anthony Fauci, Elon Musk, and Tim Berners-Lee have chosen to work in the United States due to the lucrative pay packages offered. Furthermore, high-income earners contribute significantly to the public sector through taxes, benefiting society as a whole.

On the other hand, opponents argue that excessive salaries create social problems and deepen inequality. Some of the world's wealthiest individuals have been linked to tax evasion, money laundering, and human rights violations. Moreover, income disparity widens the gap between the rich and the poor, fueling resentment and social unrest. A study by the World Bank found that countries with greater income inequality tend to experience higher rates of crime, conflict, and instability. I believe that governments should ensure that all citizens have an adequate standard of living and equal opportunities to succeed. Establishing fair income policies would promote a more democratic and prosperous society.

In conclusion, I believe that allowing individuals to earn excessively high incomes is detrimental to the country, and governments should introduce a maximum wage policy as soon as possible. By regulating salaries, societies can achieve greater economic balance and prevent disparities that hinder social progress.