Band 5 IELTS Writing Task 2 Discuss Both Views Essay on Income Levels: Coherence Issues
Sample Answer with Feedback

πŸ“… Published Apr 2026 ⏱️ 40 minutes recommended πŸ“ 258 words Β· Band 5
✏️ Start Writing for Free
Achieving a band score of 5 in IELTS indicates that some issues are present in your essay on income levels. In particular, coherence problems hinder the clarity of your arguments. This essay presents a discussion of perspectives on high incomes and the need for government limitations while also addressing the need for better organization in your writing.

IELTS Writing Task 2 Question

Discuss both views Β· High Incomes Β· 40 min


Some people in different countries earn very high incomes. While some people think that this is beneficial for the nation, others believe that the government should limit how much money people can make. Discuss both views and give your own opinion. 

Write at least 250 words.



5 Band

Overall Band Score

258 words · Discuss both views Β· AI Evaluated

5.5
Task Response
5
Coherence
5
Lexical Resource
4.5
Grammar

Score Breakdown

IELTS Writing Band Scores (1–9)

Task Response
5.5
Coherence and Cohesion
5
Lexical Resource
5
Grammatical Range and Accuracy
4.5

Summary: The essay meets the minimum word count (258 words) and addresses the topic by discussing both views and giving an opinion. However, the arguments are underdeveloped and lack depth. Coherence is affected by organizational issues and incorrect linking phrases. Vocabulary is basic with frequent spelling errors. Grammar errors are pervasive, impacting clarity and accuracy.

Now write your own β€” and see how your verdict holds up.

Submit your High Incomes essay and receive AI scores across Task Response, Coherence, Lexical Resource, and Grammar β€” plus a Band 9 model answer for your exact question.

Student Answer
Real submission β€’ 258 words β€’ Annotated
258 words Band 5 WritingPart2
● Spelling ● Grammar ● Vocabulary

Different countries,among the pulic have various income, where some earn high and others have moderate or low wages. In the essay, divided views; high income is benificial for the nation or limiting the earning by government is discussed. In my opinion, limiting the income make negative impact on nation betterment, so i am fully supporting the view which does not restrict the financial limitations.
In one hand, diverse level of wealth creates class structures like high, medium and low class society, where infrastructure development varies as the upper class has great reach and vice-versa. In the instant, a city where some people with great pay cheques want to form a similar society which lead a clear gap to the one having relatively lower pay cheques. Hunger to earn money distrubs the social values, criminal activities also take place in such situtations.
In the other hand, someone working hard and smart should be paid as their work which eventually benifit the nation as the tax is related to the amount they earn. Similarly, everyone can not succesful in the life in term of earnings, but limited people creates" title="Correction: a country focusing on limited people creates">country focusing on limited people create multiple benifits. In example, policies supporting to high income persons creates financial stability and increasse economical activities within entire nation.He/She eagers to earn more and support others.
In conclusion, there should be no limitation on wealth unless it is illegal. This also encourage other population to get in high income class.Overall, i fully support to the statement that help upper class to earn more not by limiting money.

AI Feedback Report Details

Spelling Β· Grammar Β· Vocabulary Β· Criteria Analysis

Spelling Mistakes

8 errors
Misspelled Word Corrected Word
pulic public
benificial beneficial
benifit benefit
distrubs disturbs
situtations situations
succesful successful
increasse increases
benifits benefits

Grammatical Mistakes

15 errors
Mistake Correction Explanation
among the pulic have various income among the public, have various incomes Comma placement and 'income' should be plural for clarity
divided views; divided views are Incomplete sentence fragment; need verb
limiting the income make negative impact limiting income makes a negative impact Subject-verb agreement: 'limiting income' is singular, so 'makes', and 'impact' needs article 'a'
i am fully supporting I fully support Capitalization of 'I' and verb tense; 'support' is more concise
In one hand On one hand Preposition error; correct phrase is 'on one hand'
diverse level of wealth creates diverse levels of wealth create Subject-verb agreement: 'levels' is plural, so 'create' should be plural
In the instant For instance Incorrect phrase; 'for instance' is used for examples
which lead a clear gap which leads to a clear gap Subject-verb agreement: 'which' is singular, so 'leads', and 'lead to' is the correct phrase
In the other hand On the other hand Preposition error
working hard and smart working hard and smartly 'Smart' should be 'smartly' to adverbially modify 'working'
everyone can not succesful in the life in term of not everyone can be successful in life in terms of Verb missing 'be', article 'the' should be omitted before 'life', and 'in term of' should be 'in terms of'
country focusing on limited people create a country focusing on limited people creates Article 'a' needed before 'country', and subject-verb agreement: 'country' is singular, so 'creates'
In example For example Incorrect phrase; 'for example' is standard
He/She eagers They are eager Pronoun agreement; 'He/She' is awkward, 'they' is inclusive, and 'eagers' is incorrect verb form; should be 'are eager'
encourage other population to get in encourages other populations to enter Subject-verb agreement: 'this' is singular, so 'encourages', 'population' should be plural 'populations', and 'get in' is informal; 'enter' is formal

Vocabulary Improvements

7 suggestions
Original Word/Phrase Improved Word/Phrase Explanation
nation betterment national development 'Betterment' is somewhat informal; 'development' is more academic
great pay cheques high salaries 'Pay cheques' is informal; 'salaries' is more formal
Hunger to earn money Desire to earn money 'Hunger' is metaphorical and informal; 'desire' is neutral
great reach greater access 'Reach' is vague; 'access' is more precise in context of resources
economical activities economic activities 'Economical' means cost-effective; 'economic' relates to the economy
get in enter 'Get in' is informal phrasal verb; 'enter' is more formal
limited people a limited number of people 'Limited people' is vague; 'a limited number of people' is clearer

Ready to practise? Get instant AI feedback on your verdict.

Submit your High Incomes essay and receive AI scores across all four IELTS criteria β€” with specific feedback on whether your solutions are specific, realistic, and matched to your problems.

Detailed Criteria Feedback

AI-powered analysis for each scoring criterion

Task Response 5.5
Evaluation
The response partially addresses the task by presenting both views and a clear opinion, but the development of ideas is limited. Arguments are not fully extended, and some points are vague or irrelevant (e.g., mention of criminal activities without clear connection).
Examples
The essay states 'Hunger to earn money distrubs the social values, criminal activities also take place' but does not explain how this relates to limiting incomes. The benefits of high incomes, such as tax revenue, are mentioned but not elaborated.
How to Improve
Expand on each view with specific examples and logical reasoning. Ensure all points directly relate to the topic. Provide clearer explanations for why high incomes are beneficial or harmful, and support the opinion with more detailed evidence.
Coherence and Cohesion 5
Evaluation
The essay has a basic structure with introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion. However, cohesion is weakened by incorrect transitional phrases and poor paragraph development. Ideas are not logically connected, making the flow awkward.
Examples
Incorrect use of 'In one hand' and 'In the other hand' instead of 'On one hand' and 'On the other hand'. Paragraphs jump between points without smooth transitions, e.g., from class structure to criminal activities.
How to Improve
Use accurate linking words and phrases to connect ideas. Ensure each paragraph has a clear central topic and develops it coherently. Practice organizing essays with topic sentences and supporting details.
Lexical Resource 5
Evaluation
Vocabulary is limited and repetitive, with several spelling errors and inappropriate word choices. The range is insufficient for a higher band, and some words are used incorrectly.
Examples
Misspellings: 'benificial' (beneficial), 'pulic' (public), 'distrubs' (disturbs), 'situtations' (situations). Inappropriate terms: 'pay cheques' (salaries or incomes), 'eagers' (eager).
How to Improve
Expand vocabulary by reading academic texts and practicing word usage. Use a dictionary or spell-checker to avoid errors. Aim for more precise and varied language, especially in discussing economic topics.
Grammatical Range and Accuracy 4.5
Evaluation
Grammar errors are frequent, affecting clarity and accuracy. Sentence structures are simple, and there are issues with subject-verb agreement, articles, prepositions, and verb forms.
Examples
Errors include: 'among the pulic have various income' (correct: 'among the public, there are various incomes'), 'limiting the income make negative impact' (makes a negative impact), 'He/She eagers to earn more' (He/She is eager to earn more).
How to Improve
Focus on basic grammar rules, such as subject-verb agreement and article usage. Practice constructing complex sentences correctly. Review common errors and consider using grammar exercises or tools to improve accuracy.
πŸ’‘
Tip: Review the Band 9 model answer to see how a high-scoring essay structures arguments, uses advanced vocabulary, and maintains coherence throughout.

RELATED ESSAYS

02
University Students πŸ“ 379 words ⏱️ Jul 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
There are two opposing views on whether university students should be free to choose their own subjects or whether they should only be allowed to study subjects that will be useful in the future, such as those related to science and technology. Discuss both views and give your own opinion. Write at least 250 words.
The question of what university students should study sits at the heart of what we think university is for. One side argues for total freedom of choice, the oth...
03
City Life πŸ“ 318 words ⏱️ Jul 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
Some people believe that city governments should allocate public funds only to essential urban services such as healthcare, education, and infrastructure. Others argue that investment in arts, culture, and entertainment is equally important for enhancing the quality of urban life. Discuss both views and give your own opinion. Write at least 250 words.
The health of a city and it's citizens must be given utmost priority as compared to arts, culture and entertainment. With provision of proper health...
04
High Incomes πŸ“ 330 words ⏱️ Jul 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
Some people in different countries earn very high incomes. While some people think that this is beneficial for the nation, others believe that the government should limit how much money people can make. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.  Write at least 250 words.
In different countries, many people make too much money. Some people gave their opinions in thier favour and some suggest that The Government should keeps an ey...
05
University Students πŸ“ 254 words ⏱️ Jul 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
There are two opposing views on whether university students should be free to choose their own subjects or whether they should only be allowed to study subjects that will be useful in the future, such as those related to science and technology. Discuss both views and give your own opinion. Write at least 250 words.
There are two contrary opinions about whether university students should be free to choose their own subjects or whether they should be allowed to study subject...
06
Leisure & Lifestyle πŸ“ 274 words ⏱️ Jul 2026 Band 9 Model βœ“
Some people argue that leisure time is best spent on activities that stimulate the mind, such as reading and doing word puzzles. Other people contend that leisure time is best spent on activities that relax the mind. Discuss both views and give your own opinion. Write at least 250 words.
Human beings love to relax and chill its in our nature. But it differ from a human being to another how we like to spend our leisure time some argue that free ...